Whose Canon

My friend gave me a link to a 15-minute video where some guy starts out agreeing with the principle "Sola Scriptura" (Scripture alone is our authority) and then proceeds to demolish some of the arguments for knowing exactly what constitutes Scripture, because the Bible itself does not define what is in the Bible and what is not. Which is true.

I say "some" because he did not address my perspective, which is based on history, not revelation. Taken as purely secular history, the Gospels and some of the Epistles have far greater reliability than pretty much everything else we know about ancient history. We know, without verifiable contradiction, what Jesus did and what he said. One of the things he said was that he would be executed like a criminal, and three days later he would be up and walking around again, and by God, he did. That's rather remarkable, and leads irrefutably to the conclusion that we should pay attention to the other things he said.

One of the other things he said (and acted as if he believed it) is that the Hebrew Bible -- what we now know as the Old Testament -- is God-given and absolutely true and reliable, the sole standard for how we should live. He also appointed eleven Apostles (actually twelve, but one of them died by his own hand before the Resurrection) to carry on his ministry, and to teach their successors everything. They did this by writing and approving the writing of most or all of the New Testament as we know it. There was some doubt over a small number of books now considered canonical, but those can be ignored without loss of any essential doctrine. After a few hundred years, all doubt was gone.

This is a probabilistic argument. There is a very tiny possibility that the Apostles, and after them, the early church leadership were mistaken about their choices, but all factors considered, the percentage of error is a tiny fraction of one percent, hundreds or thousands of times less likely than that I might be run over by an errant car while walking to church or crushed in my home by an airplane falling out of the sky. These things happen, but nobody worries about them. Besides, there is Pascal's Wager: even if we are wrong but act as if Scripture (as we understand it) is true and shows us the way to eternal life, the loss is minimal, a slight inconvenience to be helpful to other people, mitigated by their being helpful back, compared to the total devastation if Scripture (however understood) is true, but we "neglect so great a salvation."

After demolishing all the arguments he could think of (mine excluded) this guy then turns to granting authority to the Church established by Jesus, which is true, but then he wants to say that his particular denomination is that church. Jesus did not give a name to the church with that authority, there was only one church, and all believers were in it. Jesus did not give a location for that church, in fact he denied any specific location. The years passed on, and the church spread out over all the known world, but it was all one church...

Until Constantine became both emperor of Rome and a Christian (not necessarily in that order). Until then the titular head of the church was in Rome, and his successors have pretty much stayed there. But Constantine, for his own reasons, perhaps because he grew up there and knew the language, moved the capital of the Roman Empire to Byzantium and renamed it after himself. There were already churches there, all part of the "universal" (the Greek word is 'katholikos' Latinized to "Catholic") church, but the bishops in the new capitol wanted a more direct access to the emperor than through the Pope more than a thousand miles away (three or more months round trip for the fastest communication), so they thought up some minor doctrinal dispute and split off and separated from the church headquartered in Rome.

I see that the schism happened some 600 years after (I think it was) some emperor divided Rome from Constantinople, giving half to each of his two sons. In any case, it was Rome, not the Eastern branch, that held onto the name "universal," thereby depriving the Eastern tradition of any subsequent claim to being the true successor to the universal church founded by Jesus.

So now we have two churches, the "universal" church in Rome, and the eastern split-off in Constantinople. The guy in the video wants to believe that the eastern split-off is the only authoritative descendant of the church Jesus founded, but I did not hear him give any evidence for that claim. *I* think the church Jesus founded is still "all Christians everywhere" no matter what denomination they call themselves. It was not the Eastern Orthodox Church -- which itself has split over the years into
Greek and Russian and Aramaic, and I don't know how many other variants, each speaking their own language and each headquartered in a different city in a different country scatterd all over that part of the world -- which gave us the canon, even if it was (as this guy says) a member of one of those Orthodox churches who actually defined the 66-book canon we all now accept, but rather it was the universal church of all believers -- including, but not limited to Rome together with all the various Protestants, who all agreed to the 66-book canon in their own time -- the universal church thus authorized it.

So if this guy thinks that his particular branch of the Orthodox church authorized the canon, and therefor it is safe to obey it, that's great, but it's not a reason to join his particular denomination, because all the other denoms also authorized it. And yes, there is a very tiny probability that we got it wrong, but it's so small, it's more likely that we don't know what the true text is (which is also such a small probability that it can be safely ignored). We know what books are in the canon, and we know what they say, and most of the translations are very good translations, some with different emphases or different understandability, but no significant difference in what they tell us about God and the way to eternal life.

There is a far, far greater probility that we won't know what God said because we are not reading His Inspired Word, or we are only reading small parts of it and taking the opinions of a few teachers and pastors and bloggers like this guy, instead of reading and understanding the whole Bible ourselves. But that was not the subject of this guy's video. Maybe it should have been.

Tom Pittman
Revised 2026 October 5